A Look at Self-Directed IRAs for Private Market Investment

For investors seeking to diversify their retirement portfolios beyond traditional stocks, bonds, and mutual funds, a Self-Directed IRA (SDIRA) offers a pathway into alternative assets. You can use existing 401k's and other retirement accounts to fund your self-directed IRA. A self-directed IRA custodian can handle this process for you.

This approach allows individuals to take direct control of their retirement funds and potentially tap into the unique opportunities of real estate investments. However, this enhanced control comes with increased responsibility and a distinct set of advantages and disadvantages.

How a Self-Directed IRA for Real Estate Works

A standard IRA typically limits investment options to publicly traded securities offered by the financial institution holding the account. A Self-Directed IRA, however, is a retirement account that allows the account holder to direct their investments into a much broader range of assets, including those not traded on public exchanges, such as real estate.

To invest in private market real estate with an SDIRA, an investor must first open a self-directed account with a specialized SDIRA custodian. We can recommend a few highly regarded firms to you.

SDIRA custodians are primarily administrative, handling the paperwork, reporting, and holding the assets according to IRS regulations. They do not provide investment advice.

Once the SDIRA is established and funded (through contributions or rollovers from other retirement accounts), the individual identifies a private market real estate investment opportunity. This could range from direct ownership of a rental property, raw land, or commercial property to investing in private real estate funds or syndications. The SDIRA, through its custodian, is the legal owner of the property, not the individual. All income generated by the property (like rent) flows back into the SDIRA.

The individual cannot personally benefit from the property (e.g., live in it) or use personal funds for its expenses, as this would constitute a prohibited transaction according to IRS rules and could jeopardize the IRA's tax-advantaged status.

Disadvantages and Risks of Using an SDIRA for Private Market Real Estate:

The increased control comes with increased complexity and administrative burden. SDIRA holders are responsible for identifying, evaluating, and managing the real estate investment. For Shining Rock Equity investors, the account holder would need to carefully consider our 1-4 investment opportunities per year, to see if any of them aligns with their goals and risk tolerances.  .

There are also additional costs and fees associated with SDIRAs and real estate ownership that are not typically encountered with traditional IRA investments. These include setup and annual fees from the SDIRA custodian, although they can be very reasonable. 

Using leverage through a non-recourse loan within an SDIRA for real estate can trigger Unrelated Business Income Tax (UBIT), which may result in taxes on a portion of the income generated by the property, even within the tax-advantaged accounts.

Advantages of Using an SDIRA for Private Market Real Estate:

One of the most appealing aspects is the ability to diversify a retirement portfolio beyond the public markets. Private real estate performance often has a low correlation with stocks and bonds, potentially providing a stabilizing force during market downturns. That’s not to say that real estate does not experience volatility, but certain investments like our real estate private credit fund can offer a more stable return. This fund does not provide rescue capital which we believe reduces risk substantially. Link to actives offering page here

SDIRAs offer tax advantages. Like traditional IRAs, investments within a Traditional SDIRA grow tax-deferred, with taxes only paid upon withdrawal in retirement. In a Roth SDIRA, contributions are made with after-tax dollars, but qualified withdrawals in retirement are tax-free, including all the gains from the real estate investment. This can be particularly beneficial if the real estate appreciates significantly over time.

Investing in private market real estate provides control over investment decisions. Unlike investing in a real estate mutual fund, the SDIRA holder chooses the specific projects or funds to invest in.

In conclusion, using a Self-Directed IRA for private market real estate investment can be a powerful strategy for diversifying a retirement portfolio and potentially enhancing long-term returns. However, it requires a thorough understanding of the associated complexities, costs, and risks, as well as a willingness to take on the responsibilities of managing or overseeing the real estate asset within the confines of IRS regulations, which the SDIRA custodian can help you navigate. Let us know if you would like an introduction! 

Want to learn more?

If you are interested in learning more about passively investing in real estate, sign up for our bi-weekly newsletter and to learn about upcoming opportunities or schedule a call.